
Muhlenberg College students have voiced concerns over recent changes in healthcare accessibility and billing practices following the transition of the campus health and counseling services to Lehigh Valley Health Network (LVHN). While administrators emphasize enhanced care options, some students report unexpected fees, difficulties in scheduling counseling appointments and challenges related to insurance coverage.
The transition to LVHN was intended to integrate Muhlenberg’s health services into a larger regional network, providing students with access to a broader range of medical professionals and specialized care. However, for many students, specifically those out-of-state, this shift has introduced complications, particularly regarding insurance coverage and communication.
According to Katie Pors-Boitz, counseling director; Katherine Lutfy, practice director for LVPG Family Medicine; and Brynnmarie Dorsey, executive director of Health and Counseling Services, “Charges for office visits at the health center are billed to the student’s health insurance on file. Just as with other medical practices, any charges not covered by their insurance are the patient’s responsibility.” While LVPG accepts many insurance plans, “Students with health insurance that does not participate with LVPG are welcome and encouraged to continue using the health center. Regardless, LVPG submits charges to the student’s health insurance, and payment for services is determined after the response from the health insurance company is received. Students may also choose a “self pay” option, which offers a significant reduction in charges. Another option students can consider is purchasing the student health insurance plan offered by the college. This health insurance plan is in-network with LVPG Family Medicine–Muhlenberg College and can also be used by the student with medical providers outside our region.”
Some students who previously had no issues accessing care are now facing financial barriers. Liliana DeMoya ‘25, who has out-of-state insurance, shared, “The Health Center before the partnership with LVHN would take my insurance so I could go to them when I got sick with no problems; maybe a small co-pay but nothing major. LVHN does not take my insurance so I have to pay out of pocket for everything there. Now I have to go to Urgent Care whenever I’m sick because I can’t afford the Health Center out of pocket.”
One anonymous student expressed frustration after a Sexually Transmitted Disease (STD) test appointment. “They told me it would be free. Because they switched to LVHN, I had to see an LVHN provider before taking the test. She walked in, I told her I wanted an STD test, she walked out. The STD test itself was free, but my ‘visit with the provider’ was $87. And you can’t get an STD test without ‘seeing the provider’ first. They didn’t tell me ANY of this until the bill showed up in my account and I went in to ask them about it.”
Some students have highlighted a lack of transparency regarding billing, leading to unexpected charges. Many are calling for clearer communication about what services are covered under their insurance and what costs they might incur before receiving treatment. Rebecca Schwartz ‘27, recalled, “I was told insurance would handle it. Insurance ended [up] not covering it and I was sent a bill.”
Alyssa Kaplan ‘25 shared a similar experience: “I went to the health center for a potential injury and was asked for my insurance upon arrival. At no point during the appointment was I made aware of the possibility that it may not be accepted. After receiving a large bill months later, I was provided with minimal guidance of how to move forward, nor how to avoid such charges in the future from LVHN.”
Despite LVHN and Muhlenberg administration insisting that “there will be no charge for counseling visits,” some students have reported difficulties in reaching mental health professionals and scheduling appointments. The transition to LVHN has introduced new procedures and policies that some feel have complicated access to mental health care.
Another anonymous student explained, “Counseling services have been drastically affected for me. It’s way harder to actually locate the online form to make an appointment, and there is conflicting information on the website about whether you need to call or can use the form. All the emails of counseling services have been disabled without telling us, so I was emailing multiple times with no response because I didn’t know the emails got shut down. Additionally the counselors themselves are no longer allowed to email students due to the LVHN integration, and I was told I can’t do phone call sessions anymore because LVHN only allows in person or video calls.”
These accessibility issues have resulted in some students losing connection with their counselors entirely. “Because I can’t contact my counselor, it was impossible to let her know that I was sick and had to cancel our session. After that our sessions stopped and I haven’t used counseling since,” the student added.
Students have expressed frustration over the lack of direct communication from administrators regarding these changes. The shift in procedures has left many feeling as though they must navigate a confusing system on their own, without clear guidance on how to access the care they need.
According to Pors-Boitz, Lutfy and Dorsey, no Muhlenberg student has been denied counseling services. They emphasized, “If a student presents to our center experiencing emotional disruption or needing immediate counseling support, the student is assigned at that moment to an available counselor as a “walk-in” or “walk-in crisis” depending on severity of presenting concerns. If the student would like to start therapy, but has no immediate concerns, they will be scheduled with the earliest available counselor.”
Additionally, they clarified that LVPG Counseling Services does not bill insurance, request copays or deny services to students based on their insurance provider.
Regarding healthcare billing, Pors-Boitz, Lutfy and Dorsey explained that charges for office visits at the Health Center are billed to the student’s insurance. “Any charges not covered by their insurance are the patient’s responsibility. LVPG accepts a wide array of health insurance plans, and we encourage students to check with their insurance carrier to determine if they participate with LVPG. Regardless, LVPG submits charges to the student’s health insurance, and payment for services is determined after the response from the health insurance company is received,” they stated.
“LVHN does not take my insurance so I have to pay out of pocket for everything there.”
They also pointed out that students will not be denied care due to financial barriers and can apply for emergency grants through the Dean of Students’ Financial Hardship application if they receive bills they cannot afford. Additionally, LVHN financial counselors are available to help students navigate their insurance and payment concerns.
LVHN officials maintain that no positions were lost in the transition and that all of Muhlenberg’s registered nurses, counselors and support staff were offered employment with LVPG Family Medicine–Muhlenberg College. The majority accepted their offers, and the team has since welcomed a new counselor and patient service representative. Additionally, Katie Pors-Boitz was promoted to director of college counseling.
Some students, however, have expressed concerns about the impact of transition on their access to health services. “I think the staff changeover in the new LVHN system has made me more apprehensive about going to the health center,” said Joesphine Glass ‘27. “I think that has also made a lot of students more afraid about seeking health services at Muhlenberg and more inclined to go to health resources outside of the Muhlenberg community. I think that the lack of stability and familiar faces is a result of that. And I hope to see some permanence in resources there.”
Pors-Boitz, Lutfy and Dorsey also emphasize that the partnership has strengthened services through electronic records, improved communication and access to a larger network of providers. They highlight that the integration with LVHN provides students with a more extensive support system, though some students feel that these benefits have not yet outweighed the challenges introduced by the transition.
Still, as students continue to adjust, concerns remain. Some express hope for clearer communication, better transparency about costs and more flexibility in accessing counseling services. The College administration has stated that they are open to feedback and are working to address student concerns as they arise.
For students needing assistance, LVHN financial counselors can be reached at 484-884-0840, and the Muhlenberg College Counseling Services remains open Monday through Friday from 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
Liat Smith ’28 is thrilled to join the Muhlenberg Weekly as an assistant news editor and to contribute to such an incredible organization! She loves reading, writing, and helping others, and is so grateful for this opportunity to grow and learn. She can always be found spending time with her dorm cat, Rhea, rereading her favorite books, or watching Criminal Minds.


















