
Jo Pitera ‘25 first came into contact with “The Mad Ones” before it was even “The Mad Ones”. Originally developed under the title “The Unauthorized Autobiography of Samantha Brown”, Pitera discovered and fell in love with the musical by Kait Kerrigan and Bree Lowdermilk at 11 years old through a Tumblr post. They reflected, “Even from a young age, I was just enamored by how much emotion someone can tell in such a short amount of time, but also developing such complex relationships between a teenage girl and the people around her.” They are now preparing to open the Muhlenberg Theater Association’s (MTA) Studios Festival of Fall 2024 with the musical in its final iteration.
“The Mad Ones” tells the story of 18-year-old Samantha Brown, or “Sam” (Bella Fisher ‘25) as she sits in a hand-me-down car, reliving her senior year and deciding what direction her future is going to take. In addition to the role of Sam, the cast consists of three other characters: her imposing mother, Bev (Kayla Bassoff ‘25), her high school sweetheart, Adam (Chris Norton ‘25) and her daring best friend, Kelly (Amelia Corda ‘25), who is killed in a car wreck. Beyond “The Mad Ones” being one of their favorite musicals, Pitera wanted to direct it for Muhlenberg audiences specifically given its universal messages about growing up and choosing a path. They explained how this hits on a personal note both for them and those involved with the production in that they and the whole cast are currently seniors, meaning they can all heavily relate to the prospect of figuring out what’s next after college. They said, “I hope that the Muhlenberg audience, particularly those of us who are about to graduate, can see a lot of ourselves in the story and look back and think about how much we have changed in our time here.”
This was only exacerbated by the fact that there are also many seniors on the creative team, including Musical Director Jessica Angelitis ‘25. Angelitis elaborated on the discoveries she made while working on the music for this show: “I think that the lyrics for a lot of the songs add a lot of importance. There are many parts of the show where certain melodies will come back as a reminder for many key moments, but that leads to certain lyric changes… It adds a lot more depth to the characters, which leads to a lot of questions for the audience to wonder…and the cast captures all these feelings beautifully.”
Pitera went on to explain how directing “The Mad Ones” provided them with new insights into the piece that they did not necessarily take note of before, particularly related to understanding the headspace of the main character, Samantha Brown. They explained how the structure of the storytelling bounces back and forth between Brown’s memories and her present reality and finding both the difference and the connection between the two. This raised questions for Pitera regarding why Brown snaps out of certain memories when she does and how to convey the dreamlike nature that the musical’s blurring of reality calls for.
“Even from a young age, I was just enamored by how much emotion someone can tell in such a short amount of time…” – Jo Pitera ’25
Fisher discussed her process for bringing the character of Sam to life: “My process started with my lovely director, Jo Pitera, and I engaging in table work to analyze the script’s structure and dissect Sam’s character. So much of my version of Sam comes directly from the text, but there’s also a bit of myself sprinkled in. Something I consistently do is create a playlist of songs that I feel resembles my character’s experiences, emotional state or preferred genre of music! I will often listen to Sam’s before running the show to connect with her and to get into character!”
Their increased understanding of the main character informed Pitera’s direction for “The Mad Ones” in that they wanted to make the production as realistic as possible. Pitera’s vision contrasts with most productions of the musical in that interpretations have often resulted in what they describe as “bare bones” productions. However, Pitera expressed their hopes that emphasizing a sense of realism would contribute to the meaning of the piece both for the actors onstage as well as the audience with the statement, “It was really important to me, bringing this piece to life, to make it as realistic as possible to really help the actors in transferring back and forth between all of these memories, but also to step into a space that feels realistic enough for them to portray these emotions.” As a result, audiences can expect to see an actual working car onstage.
Pitera shared their hopes that “The Mad Ones” would resonate with all audiences: “The final song of the show is called ‘Remember This.’ There’s a theme all throughout the show–remembering things that have happened to you before, and bringing them into a new light, and recalling them when you can and how they inform you as a person. And I really hope that it reminds people to consider who they were and how it informs who they are now, but also just to take in everything around you, and enjoy. It sounds sad, but enjoy everything while you can.”
Fisher expanded upon these ideas with the statement, “I am hoping that the fun I’ve had and joy I’ve felt being in this show, and the love we’ve all put into this, shines through on stage! I hope that the audience can find moments of this beautiful story that resonate with them in some way. I know I will always cherish this show and am incredibly grateful to be a part of it.”
Samantha Tempkin '25 is a theatre and media & communication double major. During her time with The Weekly, she served as an assistant editor for News and a lead editor for Arts & Culture.


















