
The Muhlenberg Mules football team defended their home field with a sweet victory against the Gettysburg Bullets on Saturday, Oct. 19 in the “Battle of the ‘Bergs.” The Mules scored a total of 58 points, the most points scored at a home game since 2018 when the Mules beat Juniata (62-7). The Mules battled hard against the Bullets and, in the end, brought home another win, beating Gettysburg (58-42).
In an exciting offensive attempt, running backs Matthew Manning ‘26 and Amari Dunn ‘26 each found the end zone twice, demonstrating their agility and power on the ground. Wide receiver Christopher Ardito ‘25 was pivotal in the passing game, catching two touchdown passes from quarterback Joe Repetti ‘25, who controlled the offense with precision. Additionally, Andrew Darno ‘25 contributed to the scoreboard with a touchdown reception that further solidified the Mules’ lead. A standout moment came from Christopher Short ‘27, who electrified the crowd with an impressive 83-yard kickoff return for a touchdown. This remarkable play by Short makes him the fourth player in program history to return multiple kickoffs for touchdowns in a single season. Short’s return was crucial as it extended Muhlenberg’s lead to nine points after the Bullets had narrowed the score to 30-28.
Darno said, “I believe this win has a significant influence on our team’s mindset.”
Although Gettysburg quickly responded with a touchdown and a two-point conversion, the Mules regained control, scoring on their next three possessions, with Dunn rushing for another touchdown after Jake Shotwell’s ‘25 17-yard return. Shortly after, Aaron Sylvester ‘27 made a remarkable interception, his first career pick, giving the Mules prime field position at the 21-yard line. On the very first play of the fourth quarter, Repetti connected with Darno for a 21-yard touchdown, extending the lead to 51-36. The Bullets launched a strong drive but were held back by a tough Muhlenberg defense. Taking over on their 8-yard line, the Mules pulled off an impressive 11-play, 92-yard drive that consumed over half of the fourth quarter. This drive featured nine runs, mainly by Manning, smart plays by Repetti and key catches by Ardito, culminating in a 10-yard touchdown. Manning finished with 102 rushing yards on 13 carries, including a standout 31-yard touchdown run, marking his first career 100-yard game. Dunn added 41 yards, while Repetti completed 22 of 27 passes for 284 yards and achieved his 90th career touchdown. Ardito contributed seven catches for 78 yards. Defensively, Dante Mahaffey ‘26 and Owen Kovacs ‘26 each recorded 10 tackles, while Peyton Elliott ‘26 had two and a half tackles for loss. Connor Fenstermaker ‘25 had a fantastic game with a perfect 7-for-7 on extra points and his first career field goal, highlighting amazing efforts and a victory for the Mules.
Darno, when asked about the game and the team’s effort, said, “The game’s flow was marked by ups and downs until the fourth quarter, where we felt that our mistakes kept the score closer than it should have been. However, as the end of the third quarter approached, we finally started playing complementary football, supporting each other on offense and defense. This shift became especially evident during our impressive nine-minute offensive drive in the fourth quarter, where we executed plays precisely. The opposing defense struggled to respond, allowing us to extend our lead to three scores by the drive’s end, showcasing our teamwork and strategy effectively.” Darno added that this victory against Gettysburg will positively influence the team moving forward and looking ahead to next week’s home game against yet another central conference team, Dickinson College.
Darno said, “I believe this win has a significant influence on our team’s mindset. It clearly showed us that when we perform at our best and minimize our own mistakes, we can be a highly competitive force. Not many teams in the country can match us when we execute our game plan effectively. Reflecting on Saturday’s game, we realize we left a lot of opportunities on the field. Even so, we scored an impressive 58 points and won by a margin of two scores, which is a testament to our potential. This gives us confidence moving forward and reminds us that we can achieve even more. Our main focus should be on playing complementary football as we look ahead. This means working well together across all game areas, including offense, defense and special teams. Additionally, we need to actively limit personal mistakes that can undermine our efforts. By concentrating on these aspects, we can enhance our performance and continue to build on our success.” The Mules are fired up from their recent win and will head into the next game prepared and ready to come out guns blazing and bring home yet another home game conference win.

















