After a summer marked by staff cuts, faculty non-renewals and millions of dollars of deficit, students were finally able to sit down with the college’s administration and get some answers at “Campus Conversations,” the Student Government Association’s (SGA)-organized town hall held on Sept. 9. We expected this event to finally help us understand the reasoning behind the financial issues, cuts and offer us insight to the direction of the College. Instead? We got the numbers we already had, deflections to the answers we did not and were sent out no further along than when we walked in, 15 minutes before the event was scheduled to end.
After an opening and a period of general questions, students were split up into breakout rooms and given an option to swap after 15 minutes. Due to ending early, we were given about forty minutes in the “Faculty and Staff Departure” breakout room to ask our questions. In that time, only four questions were addressed, not because the student body only had four questions to ask, but because every answer was an attempt to run out the clock. Answers dragged on, repeating the same few points given for previous questions, without ever actually answering the substance of the question. For example, a student asked how the College plans to ensure professors feel secure in their jobs. The answer was not a plan but a sentiment to keep the College open for another 175 years so that our children will one day want to come here. Instead of an answer we got a slogan for the College. Furthermore, we asked how professors can prevent burnout and the answer we got was essentially “assign less work.” This isn’t just a bad answer, it’s an admission that the quality of our education is expected to decline. If professors are being told to assign less work to manage the fallout of these cuts, that means less feedback, shorter assignments and a less rigorous education and we’re the ones absorbing that cost.
To say that the community conversation was a disappointment would be an understatement. This event was created by SGA because students demanded real answers and it was supposed to be the venue to receive those answers. However, the same administration that spent the summer responding to student concerns with automated FAQ responses instead of direct conversation used this opportunity to repeat the same deflections we received in our inboxes all summer, only now face-to-face. SGA has given them plenty of opportunities to answer these concerns in other town halls, yet they continue to waste our time. But it’s not just about wasted time. It’s about what all of this is actually costing us. What are we actually paying for anymore?
When we committed to Muhlenberg College, we were promised a different version of the College we now know. Promises of small class sizes have now been completely abandoned by our administration. Personal connections with professors will now be harder to obtain as not only will our classes be bigger, but previous connections will now be lost as the administration cuts our professors. Our community is divided among the actual people who make up our community and those who run the College. While the actual community works hard at maintaining ourselves, our administration continues to make senseless decisions that dig the hole even deeper. We build new buildings yet lose the people we need to fill them. This is more than just one mistake.
This isn’t a one-time miscommunication; this is a repeated pattern. Any direct question is met with an answer with no substance and a redirect to someone else. We are done accepting sentiments in place of plans, and redirecting in place of accountability. The student body has plenty of questions for the administration, and it is about time we finally get answers to them. Questions about sustaining affected programs, why the College failed to communicate over the summer and where our money is going have still not been addressed. We need an administration that truly wants to be transparent, not one that just likes to appear so. As a student body we cannot continue to wait for the administration to decide when we get to ask. This Friday, Sept. 18 at 2 p.m. on Academic Row, Mules For Transparency is bringing a whiteboard to campus: write your question, and we’ll make sure it ends up in front of the administration. Let’s put them somewhere they can’t ignore.


















