Response to “Concerns over academic freedom amidst Trump directives”
In the March 27, 2025 edition of The Muhlenberg Weekly, an article entitled “Concerns over academic freedom amidst Trump directives” appeared to downplay the failure of Columbia University to respond substantially to a climate of pervasive discrimination against Jewish students. While we agree with the precepts of freedom of speech and academic freedom, we were concerned by the choice of the word “alleged” in reference to Columbia University’s response (or lack thereof) to campus antisemitism.
We believe that the diction of “alleged” warrants reconsideration, as it risks reframing criticism of the University’s inexplicably restrained response to antisemitism as unfounded or unreasonable. Columbia itself acknowledged its own negligence in August 2024, over six months ago, when the second report from their Task Force on Antisemitism stated that repeated antisemitic incidents on campus are “evidence of a broken social compact” and that the university is “failing to create an inclusive campus environment.”
We were also troubled by The Weekly’s choice to not seek comments from Hillel student leaders in an article which details events that disproportionately affect Jewish students. Looking ahead, we sincerely encourage The Weekly to discuss topics such as these with the wider Jewish community so that a more holistic and inclusive conversation about the worrying increase of antisemitism at institutions such as Columbia may consider the opinions of those who are most aware and threatened by such disturbing trends.
Hudson Plaskoff ‘28
Emily Fulton ‘28
Brandon Rosenblatt ‘27
Gavrielle Cohen ‘27
Hana Feig ‘27
It is the policy of The Muhlenberg Weekly to foster relationships with its readership, including through discourse in its Opinion/Editorial section. Therefore, members of the College Community are encouraged to submit Letters to the Editor on any topic of interest to Muhlenberg, in direct reference to an article or otherwise.

















