Home Campus Voices Letter to the Editor

Letter to the Editor

Commitment to Academic Freedom and Community Values

830

Dear Editor,

We know that some members of our campus community have questions and concerns about the application of college policy, specifically our equal opportunity policies, in regard to an ongoing faculty personnel matter. For some, this is a difficult topic and it has been made more challenging by reporting in the media and by some advocacy groups that are not consistent with the facts. We appreciate our community’s ongoing respect for Muhlenberg’s processes.  

This is a challenging situation. Because it pertains to a member of the faculty, some have raised an important question: Where is the boundary between academic freedom and professional misconduct? 

To be perfectly clear about academic freedom and our policies:

Muhlenberg College is deeply committed to freedom of expression and scholarly inquiry. Our guiding principle is the American Association of University Professors’ (AAUP) 1940 Statement of Principles on Academic Freedom and Tenure, which guarantees teachers fundamental freedoms in their research, the classroom, and their speech as private citizens. It also imposes “special obligations” on faculty, both in carrying out their duties on campus and as representatives of their institutions in private life. This is fundamental to who we are, and we will not compromise when it comes to this core tenet of American higher education. We are dedicated to maintaining a community in which our students, faculty and staff can freely pursue and create knowledge through scholarly inquiry and civil discussion and debate.

The College lives these values every day by providing a scholarly forum where diverse, sometimes controversial ideas can be discussed and debated. Muhlenberg welcomes speakers who offer a variety of perspectives on scholarly and societal topics. Already this fall, the Center for Ethics, the Election series, the Red Door Roots initiative and WorldViews programming are examples of how diverse viewpoints have enriched the intellectual discourse on campus. In addition, the College supports our students, staff and faculty as they express their political and societal perspectives through active civic engagement.

To guarantee our community’s ability to speak and learn freely, we have a robust policy structure that outlines clear rules, guidelines and processes to address allegations of discriminatory behavior and other alleged misconduct. In faculty employment matters, the College consistently follows the procedures set forth in our Equal Opportunity and Nondiscrimination Policy, as well as the Faculty Handbook, in conjunction with the College’s overarching policies and the law. 

In short, we are committed to providing a challenging and supportive learning environment where every student can access the robust educational opportunities offered at Muhlenberg without fear of reprisal. Hatred and bigotry have no place on our campus, and the College will not tolerate threatening or intimidating behavior. 

The current faculty personnel matter is under review by an elected faculty committee. Its work is ongoing in accordance with the procedures approved by the faculty and outlined in the Muhlenberg Faculty Handbook. At the conclusion of the review, the committee will submit recommendations, and the College will conclude the matter with a final determination. This will take some time. The specifics of this case will remain confidential. In the same way that we protect students’ academic, health and other records, we treat employee records and related processes as confidential. 

The goal of a liberal arts education is not simply to take a variety of courses. It is about developing specific habits of mind and powers of expression that arise from constructively negotiating diverse perspectives and difficult issues. It is about the ability of students, faculty and staff to pursue knowledge, create new knowledge and express themselves freely without fear of reprisal.

These freedoms are at the core of American higher education, and we will continue to enact and enforce policies that protect them. 

Sincerely,
Kathleen Harring, Ph.D.
President
Laura Furge, Ph.D.
Provost

+ posts

It is the policy of The Muhlenberg Weekly to foster relationships with its readership, including through discourse in its Opinion/Editorial section. Therefore, members of the College Community are encouraged to submit Letters to the Editor on any topic of interest to Muhlenberg, in direct reference to an article or otherwise.